Repair or Replace Your HVAC? The $5,000 Rule Explained

A simple way to decide whether to repair or replace your AC, heat pump or furnace is the $5,000 rule: multiply the age of the system in years by the cost of the repair. If the result is more than $5,000, replacing the system usually makes more financial sense. If it’s less, repair it.

The rule is a starting point, not the whole answer. Below is how to use it, when to break it, and a checklist that covers the factors it leaves out.

How the $5,000 rule works

Age (years) × repair cost ($) = score

  • Under $5,000: repair.
  • Over $5,000: seriously consider replacing.
System ageRepair costScoreSuggestion
5 years$450 (capacitor)2,250Repair
8 years$1,200 (fan motor + service)9,600Check warranty first; often repair if parts are covered
12 years$350 (contactor)4,200Repair
12 years$1,800 (refrigerant leak)21,600Replace
15 years$600 (blower motor)9,000Replace, or repair only as a short-term bridge
18 years$250 (igniter)4,500Repair, but start budgeting for replacement

Some contractors use a higher threshold, such as $6,000 to $7,000, because equipment prices have risen. Treat anything between $5,000 and $7,000 as a gray zone where the other factors below should decide.

Typical lifespan of HVAC equipment

EquipmentTypical lifespan
Central air conditioner12 to 15 years
Heat pump10 to 15 years
Gas furnace15 to 20+ years
Boiler20 to 30 years
Ductless mini split12 to 20 years
Ductwork20 to 30 years

Climate matters: an AC in Phoenix works far harder than one in Minneapolis, and a coastal unit faces salt corrosion.

When to repair even if the score is high

  • The part is under warranty. Many systems carry a 10-year parts warranty if registered. A covered compressor may cost only labor. Check with the manufacturer using your model and serial number.
  • You plan to move soon. A repair can make more sense than a new system you won’t use for long.
  • The system was well maintained and has had few problems.
  • Budget timing. A repair can buy time to save, compare quotes, or wait for the off-season.

When to replace even if the score is low

  • Your system uses R-22. R-22 production ended in 2020 and recharges are very expensive. See our R-410A phase-out guide for how refrigerants affect your decision.
  • Frequent breakdowns. Two or more significant repairs in two years is a warning sign.
  • Rising energy bills with no change in usage.
  • Comfort problems the system can’t solve: hot or cold rooms, high humidity, constant running.
  • Safety concerns: a cracked furnace heat exchanger or repeated carbon monoxide alarms. Replace immediately and stop using the furnace until it’s inspected.

Repair vs. replace checklist

Give one point for each “yes”:

  1. The system is older than 12 years (AC or heat pump) or 15 years (furnace).
  2. Age × repair cost is over $5,000.
  3. It uses R-22.
  4. It has needed two or more major repairs in the past two years.
  5. Energy bills have risen noticeably.
  6. Some rooms are uncomfortable or humidity is hard to control.
  7. The repair is a compressor, heat exchanger or coil.
  8. The equipment is out of warranty.

0 to 2 points: repair. 3 to 4: get a repair quote and a replacement quote and compare. 5 or more: replacement is likely the better investment.

Compare the real costs

RepairReplace
Up-front costLowerHigher: often $6,000 to $12,000 for central AC
Energy billsUnchangedLower with a more efficient system
Future repairsLikely, as other parts ageCovered by new warranty for years
ComfortUnchangedCan improve, especially with two-stage or variable-speed

See current prices: AC repair cost and central AC replacement cost.

Questions to ask your contractor

  • What exactly failed, and how did you test it?
  • Is the part covered by the manufacturer’s warranty?
  • What other parts are worn and likely to fail soon?
  • What would a replacement cost, and what size system does my home need? Ask for a Manual J.
  • Is this repair a long-term fix or a short-term bridge?

Be cautious if a contractor pushes replacement on a young system for a minor repair, or recommends repeated refrigerant top-offs without finding the leak.

Frequently asked questions

Is it worth repairing a 15-year-old AC?

Small repairs can be worth it. For anything major, such as a compressor, coil or refrigerant leak, replacement is usually the better choice at that age.

How much should I spend on repairing an old furnace?

Use the same rule: if the furnace’s age times the repair cost is over $5,000, consider replacing it, especially if it’s over 15 years old.

Does replacing an AC increase home value?

A newer system is a selling point and can help a home sell faster, though you rarely recover the full cost in the sale price.

Disclaimer: this guide is for general information only. Decisions about safety components like furnace heat exchangers should always be made with a licensed HVAC professional.